Ramsey or Rattay as a future NFL star?

[corky]

Which of these guys is more likely to be a star in the future, looking ahead past this year.

[steelyeri]

I like ramsey myself. I would have liked to see what he can do with a better team around him. I dislike very much the Mark Brunell pickup, Ramsey is the Redskin's future and this hinders his development. Rattay looked good as well last season though.

[corky]

or Drew Henson, I guess you could throw him in there as well.

[CC]

I think Drew Henson has the best chance of any of them.

[Gilstrap11]

I think NFL star may be pushing it a little. I think Ramsey has the most potential of the two just by looking at which way each orginization is heading.

[maddog60]

Ramsey I think has the most talent, but management in Washington has been really screwy of late. Even with Gibbs making Brunell the starter when Ramsey desperately needs to be playing and developing right now.

[Shatner8]

Rattay looks to be in the best situation therefore i think i would go with him

[Homeless]

Not a fan of Ramseys so i'd have to go with Rattay.

[NittanyLions]

I think Ramsey is the better QB, but given the situations, I think Rattay is the better one

[MCG321]

Ramsey has shown some good stuff. If the Redskins actually choose to use him (and protect him), I think he'll be a star someday.