whats the better game? madden or ncaa football

[Guest]

personally ive always liked ncaa more , basically because it plays just as good as madden and its just deeper i think with all of the things that u can win ( heisman rivalry trophies etc..) along with a lot more teams. any way thats what i think. what do u like better?

[badass32]

sorry i forgot to login

[Free Bagel]

First off, there's a video game forum for this kind of stuff, though I'm sure this will be moved there.

Secondly:

because it plays just as good as madden

I disagree 100% with the idea that NCAA plays just as good as Madden. I like NCAA, but the gameplay is nowhere near the level of Madden. The camera is more 'zoomed out' and everything seems smaller, making micromanagement more difficult. Also, the AI is 1000x worse than in madden. Even on the highest difficulty setting in NCAA bombs are completely dumb looking, the WR runs in place and the ball just appears in their hands while the DB's make no moves at all, at least in madden the WR's jump and make it look like they're actually in position to catch the ball.

[hayesb26]

Bagel is right. The play is much better in Madden than in NCAA. Also, the thing that pisses me off about NCAA is that they can't have the players names. If they did, I'd buy it every year.

[joester]

I agree that Madden is wayyyyyyyy better than NCAA. The plays and gameplay are better.

[NittanyLions]

Yeah, MAdden is better play, and just as deep. I agree, having the names would be so much cooler. Madden beats NCAA

[Vikes_Fan2823]

Nittany and Hayes, you guys are both retarded.

They can't put the names into the college football games because the college football players don't have a player's association. They don't have a player's association because they are amateurs. Having a player's association breaks their amateur status. Got it? So stop whining, you can see their names when they go pro.

[terpfan]

Nittany and Hayes, you guys are both retarded.

They can't put the names into the college football games because the college football players don't have a player's association. They don't have a player's association because they are amateurs. Having a player's association breaks their amateur status. Got it? So stop whining, you can see their names when they go pro.

its still annoying.

[Azrael]

Madden WAS better until NCAA put Fitz on the cover this year...and he's still in the game *drool*

[hayesb26]

Nittany and Hayes, you guys are both retarded.

They can't put the names into the college football games because the college football players don't have a player's association. They don't have a player's association because they are amateurs. Having a player's association breaks their amateur status. Got it? So stop whining, you can see their names when they go pro.

I don't know who the hell you are, but why don't you actually read my damn post! I said that they "can't" have the player names. I know about the PA and all of that, I'm not a moron. Obviously somebody needs to learn how to read before running his mouth

Anyways, this is a discussion about two games and which is better. You did nothing to contribute to the discussion, so get out!