I have to say Madden. It has better graphics, better tackling sequences and of course PLAYMAKER! That is what puts it over the top of NCAA Football. Although I like NCAA Football alot, sometimes better than the Madden series, I have to say Madden in the better line of games. Also, I don't like the fact that when you upload a draft class, the player ratings are the same. I thin kthey should drop the overall rating on a scale of 12-18 points. But that's just my personal opinion.