Defensive TDs are a crapshoot anyways, I wouldn't rely on them as a judge of a defense. I would rank them
Dallas
Tenn
TB
STL
Dallas should only get better, while TB is getting old and STL lost the coordinator.
Flux wrote:TB - the loss of Lynch and Sapp dont help them
Paying no attention to them don't help.
The Bucs still have the best D of the teams listed. They were ranked in the top 5(2nd I think, I could be wrong), and they've added Ian Gold who is much better than Ryan Nece, even if he isn't 100%. They lost Lynch, but Jermaine Phillips is the same thing, hits hard, solid run D, no so great in coverage. But losing the experience hurts of course. But most importantly in the secondary, they still have a top CB in Ronde Barber. They get back Brian Kelly, one of the best #2s in the league. And they add Mario Edwards a solid nickel CB. Last year they got burned by injuries and were forced to have Tim Wansley, a 7TH ROUND ROOKIE lining up against the likes of Jimmy Smith and Marvin Harrison. We all know how that went. The line still has Rice, Booger, and Wyms who is solid. I expect them to take a step forward this year.
All of these will be different this year because they all lost key components of their D:
Dallas actually has not lost much, but gained more. didnt they they lose mario edwards their starting corner? but overall the D improved.
TB lost big Warren Sapp and John Lynch, I dont think Lynch's absence will effect them because he was hurt last year also.
Tenn lost a whole bunch of D-Lineman.
STL lost their coach.
TheOneManShow 26 wrote:All of these will be different this year because they all lost key components of their D: Dallas actually has not lost much, but gained more. didnt they they lose mario edwards their starting corner? but overall the D improved. TB lost big Warren Sapp and John Lynch, I dont think Lynch's absence will effect them because he was hurt last year also. Tenn lost a whole bunch of D-Lineman. STL lost their coach.
So the order would be Dallas, STL, Tenn, TB
What? STL is clearly inferior to the other teams. Why do you have them #2??? Tennessee also lost their best player on D, but Randy Starks should play decent. Dallas and TB are the top 2 of this list. Tennessee and STL just plain aren't as good. Hell, Tampa had a down year defensively and they were still ahead of Tenn and STL in points allowed, yards allowed, and turnovers.
Flux wrote:TB - the loss of Lynch and Sapp dont help them
Paying no attention to them don't help.
The Bucs still have the best D of the teams listed. They were ranked in the top 5(2nd I think, I could be wrong), and they've added Ian Gold who is much better than Ryan Nece, even if he isn't 100%. They lost Lynch, but Jermaine Phillips is the same thing, hits hard, solid run D, no so great in coverage. But losing the experience hurts of course. But most importantly in the secondary, they still have a top CB in Ronde Barber. They get back Brian Kelly, one of the best #2s in the league. And they add Mario Edwards a solid nickel CB. Last year they got burned by injuries and were forced to have Tim Wansley, a 7TH ROUND ROOKIE lining up against the likes of Jimmy Smith and Marvin Harrison. We all know how that went. The line still has Rice, Booger, and Wyms who is solid. I expect them to take a step forward this year.
1st of all, TB was not the best defense of the group. DAL finished 1st in giving up the fewest yards per game, and 2nd in giving up the fewest pts per game. TB finished 5th and 4th respectively.
2ndly, Sapp and Lynch may very well have seen better days, but they were still the heart and soul of that team and defense and will definitely be missed for their emotion and leadership.