Unorthodox QB settings.

[roninmedia]

In both leagues 1 & 2, the settings for all the other players are standard nfl.com/sportsline/espn seetings. But QBs are different.


League 1 (Receptions are also worth 1 pt)
Completions (1)
Passing Yards (20 yards per point)
Passing Touchdowns (4)
Interceptions (-1)

League 2
Passing Yards (25 yards per point)
Passing Touchdowns (6)
Interceptions (-2)
Sacks (-1)


How would you rate the the top 10 qbs in league 1 and 2? And in league 1, how much more valuable do they suddenly become?

[CC]

I dont want to do them all but Manning is #1 in the 1st league and Cully is #1 in the second league.

[roninmedia]

According to league 1, Peyton Manning would have garned roughly 684 fantasy pts over the entire NFL season last year which is ridiculous.

[The Lung]

League 1 (Receptions are also worth 1 pt)
Completions (1)
Passing Yards (20 yards per point)
Passing Touchdowns (4)
Interceptions (-1)

This system obviously favors the quarterback with the most completions.

Here's the top 10, and the results may surprise some of you:

Peyton Manning IND 379
Brad Johnson TB 354
Marc Bulger STL 336
Trent Green KC 330
Jon Kitna CIN 324
Tom Brady NE 317
Matt Hasselbeck SEA 313
Joey Harrington DET 309
Brett Favre GB 308
Aaron Brooks NO 306

[Franchise Fan]

I dont want to do them all but Manning is #1 in the 1st league and Cully is #1 in the second league.

agree totally