rate these bench RB's

[arrbez]

-garner
-staley
-martin
-barber
-hearst
-shipp

[Cornbread Maxwell]

really nothing more than educated guesses here, but this is the way i thnk it will happen:

staley - 75% of a RBBC
shipp - best breakout candidate in the group - may not be in a RBBC
martin - 66% of a RBBC
garner - 66% of a RBBC, but isnt a TD threat
barber - 60% of a RBBC, fumble issues, losses goalline touches


hearst - just a mentor at this point.

[KingGhidra]

-garner
-staley
-martin
-barber
-hearst
-shipp

Barber: Still the man. Still a 70 catch RB.
Martin: Still a 330 carry stud until his legs fall off.
Staley: Best of what's left. Good talent on a horrendous team.
Garner: Good talent. Old on a mediocre team that plays to his strengths.
Shipp: Umm yeah...
Hearst: 3rd down back at most probably.

[Azrael]

Barber
Martin
Staley
Shipp
Garner
Hearst

[TheBigBakedBean]

I'll go:

-> Shipp
-> Martin
-> Staley
-> Garner
-> Hearst
-> Barber

I'm certainly not a Tiki Barber fan...so maybe I'm bias.

[irishdude103]

Shipp
Barber
Martin
Staley
Garner
Hearst

[arrbez]

wow, i thought shipp would consistantly be ranked at the top because he's the only clear cut #1 (emmit smith? let's be reasonable here) in the group. howcome some of you guys are ranking him so low? think he still wont be able to find the endzone?

[Buckychudd]

wow, i thought shipp would consistantly be ranked at the top because he's the only clear cut #1 (emmit smith? let's be reasonable here) in the group. howcome some of you guys are ranking him so low? think he still wont be able to find the endzone?

Shipp had his chance last year, and averaged a whole 3.6 ypc. He doesn't fit well into Green's offensive scheme, and is sitting 2nd on the depth chart.

Personally, I think he's the worst of the bunch.

[IRON CHEF]

I thought the Emmit was starting this year.

[irishdude103]

I thought the Emmit was starting this year.

he is, but Marcell is said to be moving in on the job