My QB Rankings

[kid a]

I would not put Leftwitch that high. He needs another year before becoming a top QB. He made a lot of mistakes last year and I think some of that will continue at least through the 1st half of this season. I got him around #15 right now prolly in the top 10 for next year if his progress is good this year.

Actually, I have him that high because I think he'll fall far enough into the draft to have great value. I'm eyeing him as my #2 QB because he has the potential to be a top 10 QB or more this season, and because if he is a bust, he won't have to be taken early enough to kill your team.

I'm sure the mistakes will be there, but they're not going to pull him and I actually like the Jacksonville offense a lot this season.

And it looks like he's a common sleeper pick around these parts, a lot of people are high on him. I know I won't be calling his name too early, but I like the upside way more than a guy like David Carr. (who I also wouldn't mind as a backup)

[Shatner8]

1. Cpepp
2. Manning
3. Mcnabb
4. Vick
5. Hassleback
6. Pennington
7. Mcnair
8. Green
9. Brooks
10. Garcia

[goleafsgo96]

1. Cpepp
2. Manning
3. Mcnabb
4. Vick
5. Hassleback
6. Pennington
7. Mcnair
8. Green
9. Brooks
10. Garcia

as usual, i really agree with shatners rankings. Although i would switch cpepp with manning, but other than that this all looks good.

[deftdelivery]

1 - Culpepper
2 - Manning
3 - McNabb
4 - Vick
5 - Hasselbeck
6 - Bulger
7 - McNair
8 - Green
9 - Brooks
10 - Brady

[TheBigBakedBean]

All you people with Vick in the top 10 (some even have him in the top 5!) are going to AGAIN be S.O.L. when he breaks something in the preason. Personally, I'm going to let him play 16 games in a single season before thinking of drafting him.

[fantasizing]

All you people with Vick in the top 10 (some even have him in the top 5!) are going to AGAIN be S.O.L. when he breaks something in the preason. Personally, I'm going to let him play 16 games in a single season before thinking of drafting him.

I'd like to wait a full season and see what he can do also. IMO, I think he is way over-rated. He's got talent, but there have been many prospects out there that have failed to deliver through history. Until he passes for 3000+ yards and gets 20+ passing TDs to go along with his 800 yards rushing, 7 Tds rushing (which we all assume he will get), I'll pass on him.

[bagobonez]

Finally, someone sees it my way on Vick. Yes, he's got all the talent in the world, but let's see him stay healthy 16 games and actually show he can be a proficient passer before we move him into the top 3. The same can be said about McNabb to a lesser extent.

Hasselbeck and Green are underated.

[IRON CHEF]

I ranked them based on how talented they were, not necessarily the order I would draft them in. For example I would probably never get the top 3 because they always are picked way too early. I look to usually wait it out and see who is available later.

[SpiderLockhart43]

Personally, I'd drop Mcnabb and McNair back a couple and bring Hasselbeck and Green up.

I don't think Phillies running game is going to get much respect, so the production of Owens won't be the same as when he was in SF.
McNair - durability is a question mark, and a decline in the team overall.

I think Hasselbeck and Green are up and coming.

I was able to pick up Bulger in the 4th round 6th pick in a 10 team league on ESPN and Yahoo.

My top 10 rankings
Culpepper
Vick
Manning
Hasselbeck
Bulger
McNabb
Green
Harrington
McNair
Brooks

[SpiderLockhart43]

Looking Again I think I'd drop Brooks off my top 10 list and put Brunell there.
I think Brunell is going to have a big year and could possibly be picked up as late as the 7th round.
Look at the offense Wash has...with Brunell Portis and Coles, I think Redskins are going to score some decent FFL pts.