My QB Rankings

[KingGhidra]

Until he passes for 3000+ yards and gets 20+ passing TDs to go along with his 800 yards rushing, 7 Tds rushing (which we all assume he will get), I'll pass on him.

So you basically want what he already did in 2002.

2936 yards 16 TD 8 INT 777 rushing yards 8 TDs

By the way he finished 2nd.

[bagobonez]

Looking Again I think I'd drop Brooks off my top 10 list and put Brunell there.
I think Brunell is going to have a big year and could possibly be picked up as late as the 7th round.
Look at the offense Wash has...with Brunell Portis and Coles, I think Redskins are going to score some decent FFL pts.

Brunell ahead of Brooks? When has Brunell ever been a stat monster? Even in his hay-day when the Jaguars had Jimmy Smith and Keenan McCardell in their primes, Brunell never put up big numbers.

[deftdelivery]

All you people with Vick in the top 10 (some even have him in the top 5!) are going to AGAIN be S.O.L. when he breaks something in the preason. Personally, I'm going to let him play 16 games in a single season before thinking of drafting him.

Which is why I'm waiting for a QB like Green or Pennington to slip to me, and refusing to draft a top 5 QB unless he sliiiiiides all the way down. And if Vick slides to the friggan 6th-7th round (which he wont) Why not take a shot. I'd rather draft thinking upside than b*tching about downside all the time.

[IRON CHEF]

I think Brunell is going to have a big year and could possibly be picked up as late as the 7th round.

He is in position to have a fine year a little outside the top 11.

[TheBigBakedBean]

Brunell ahead of Brooks? When has Brunell ever been a stat monster? Even in his hay-day when the Jaguars had Jimmy Smith and Keenan McCardell in their primes, Brunell never put up big numbers.

Brings up a good point...

[Bennett4prez]

Ah, the comforts of those cautios owners. I love the guys that let players like Vick, Freddy, and Bennett fall due to injury. Vick is a top 5 QB when healthy. Right now, he is healthy. Until the time happens when he breaks something, he stays there.

[SunnydaleSpike]

1. Manning
2. Culpepper
3. Hasselbeck
4. McNair
5. Green
6. Brooks
7. Favre
8. McNabb
9. Vick
10.Pennington

[kid a]

Brunell ahead of Brooks? When has Brunell ever been a stat monster? Even in his hay-day when the Jaguars had Jimmy Smith and Keenan McCardell in their primes, Brunell never put up big numbers.

Not too mention, doesn't Gibbs run a somewhat conservative offense? And Brunell isn't exactly Favre, if and when he suffers an injury Ramsey could step in and steal the job here.