Keenan McCardell...

[WTA]

Should I hold on to McCardell and pray he plays this year, or go ahead and try to trade him now while somebody might take a shot on him before he makes an official decision??

[arrbez]

i would avoid him like the plague right now. even if he does play, it sounds like galloway will be the #1. and i cant see him getting many touchdowns this year, with galloway and jurevicious being better deep and redzone threats

[kvnhbbrd]

Trade him, your squad is strong enough without him. To risky for sucha small return if any.

[steelerfan04]

Trade him. No way he can repeat last years numbers.

[tmandpimp]

you gotta ask the bucs fans such as myself. nobody likes him BUT i bet you two things if i know the bucs

#1 he will play
#2 he will do well
#3 galloway will help him get even more looks
#4 M clayton will suck
#5 unless joe J. comes back then Joey and K will split the ball cause tampa will never be able to run untill they give Mike Alstott the ball 25-30 a game for a season.(even though they are gonna cut or trade him next year)

[tmandpimp]

thats more than two but i got excited about the bucs

[Turnip]

#4 M clayton will suck

I know bucs fans weren't thrilled when this guy was drafted, but in my opinion he will be the second best receiver (career wise) out of this draft after Fitzgerald (Yes before Roy). The dude is a very special playmaker WR in my opinion.

[Football Newbie]

I put him up for trade in the NNKL for a wet paper bag or a moiste towlette. I suggest you do the same.

[cooleyhigh]

At this point his value is nada unless you find a dope. I would hold him until

1) he returns, tail between his legs, to TB or...
2) he is cut and signs someplace needing a WR

Buy low, sell high...

[TheHeat24]

I know bucs fans weren't thrilled when this guy was drafted, but in my opinion he will be the second best receiver (career wise) out of this draft after Fitzgerald (Yes before Roy). The dude is a very special playmaker WR in my opinion.

Roy Williams will be the best receiver in this draft, out of all the receivers taken in the first round I think clayton is the least playmaker-like (dont know how to phrase it) Fitz can jump, and catch like no other, Roy Williams has burners and is dominant when he gets the ball in his hands, Lee Evans is a huge Deep Threat, Reggie Williams brings great size and good speed and is a great Red Zone Target, I would exclude Rashaun Woods from this list but in College he had 6 tds in a game which are playmaker numbers...

Dont you think there is a reason the bills passed on him even thopugh he seems like more of a prototypical number 2 receiver, he doesnt have the speed to be a huge playmaker... He is exactly like keyshawn and thats why they drafted him, Hes a great run blocker and will catch everything across the middle but he wont be a 1400-1600yd receiver like Larry or Ro'....