In your situation, taking J Lew would be the better the choice since he is your #2. But I wouldn't take a guy who is nearly guaranteed to miss time as my 1st rd pick if I could avoid it.
After the stud 6, Edge, Fred, and Moss I would have to opt for Lewis, albeit grudgingly. The guy could get convicted and he will be lost during fantasy playoff season.
...so much risk for a #1.