Emmit looks horrible, bring on Scobey!!!

[Patsy Player]

Seriously......Grampa Emmit...please step aside.

[Favre.com]

anyone with half a brain knew that the Emmit signing was a publicity stunt to try to get the seats filled. He is old and washed up and needs to be replaced, Shipp (IMO) is an amazing talent but with his injury I'd rather see Scobey.

[IRON CHEF]

I would hesitate to call Shipp an amazing talent, but he was a better option than Ol Emmitt. I'm liking Scobey as a sleeper, but it depends on how Zona plans to use Damien Andersen.

[littletank]

Being a Kstate grad, I would love seeing Scobey playing. I think he definately has the talent to do well.

[Impressionable]

I would hesitate to call Shipp an amazing talent, but he was a better option than Ol Emmitt. I'm liking Scobey as a sleeper, but it depends on how Zona plans to use Damien Andersen.

Ugh, I just don't see someone who would normally be 4th on the depth chart behind Shipp, Emmitt, and Anderson as a huge sleeper. He has talent, but everyone in the NFL has talent. If you're drafting him to expect much at all, I wouldn't hold my breath.

[The Guru]

Anyone know what game week Shipp is expected to come back in?

[aussieboy]

Im wondering whether or not I should pick up Scobey off WW.

I think its only a matter of time before Emmitt either gets injured or is replaced.

Shipp's injured has him sidelined for 8-12weeks, that was around 3 or so weeks ago i think. His injury is quite serious. So if Scobey does claim the #1 RB role will he be able to hold off Shipp when Shipp returns?

[GMoney]

i truely think that if arizona can put otgeather anything that looks like a running game shipp is done for.... i have no faith in his ability to come back and regain a backup job even.

its not like LT is injured and as soon as the man was relatively healhty they would start him and put up with some bad games until hes fully recovered....

shipp will have to spend weeks and weeks in practice trying to prove to green that he is better than everyone else.... and by that time its way to late for him in my opinion.....

[Favre.com]

i truely think that if arizona can put otgeather anything that looks like a running game shipp is done for.... i have no faith in his ability to come back and regain a backup job even.

its not like LT is injured and as soon as the man was relatively healhty they would start him and put up with some bad games until hes fully recovered....

shipp will have to spend weeks and weeks in practice trying to prove to green that he is better than everyone else.... and by that time its way to late for him in my opinion.....

Yeah, I don't agree with this at all. Look at Shipp's current production, he is clearly the future, before Emmit he WAS the starter, now some guy that no one has ever seen would come in and you think they will just give the job to him? Shipp comes back = he is the MAIN GUY. Hes proven, for the most part a lot more then Scobey and unless Scobey puts up monster numbers (like Rudi Jonhson did in Dillon's absense) Shipp will be the feature back asap.

[AGENT]

The question I have is who will be the better producer this year. Andrson or Scobey. I picked up Scobey off the waiver wire hoping he will get a chance to be the man once Emmitt gets hurt