RB's by tier....

[Plindsey88]

I posted this in another thread, but thought I'd give it it's own forum for discussion without hijacking the other topic:

Here are my RB rankings by tier for this season....

Holmes
LT2
-----------
Green
-----------
Deuce
Alexander
Portis
Edge
-----------
Jamal
Taylor
-----------
Barlow
Dillon
Dom Davis
Rudi Johnson
-----------
Westbrook
Henry
Faulk
Griffin
Brown
S. Davis
T. Jones
Bennett
------------
Barber
Suggs
Martin
Staley
------------
Wheatley
Dunn
Garner
K. Jones
------------
George
E. Smith
Minor

All the number 2 guys J. Jones, McGahee, Foster, Wm. Green, Ron Dayne, etc... fit in here somewhere, but everyone has them in different places...

What do you think?

[Autumn Wind]

I would put Henry at the top of the 5th tier (although he is borderline 4th with Taylor)....I think he is going to have a great year and he is very undervalued

[Warpigs]

Looking at your tiers -- if Jamal Lewis' situation wasn't threatened by missed time at court, how far up would he move?

[BrutallyHuge]

Although in the same tier, I like Rudi better than Domanick and Corey.

[Plindsey88]

Looking at your tiers -- if Jamal Lewis' situation wasn't threatened by missed time at court, how far up would he move?

If Jamal was not a question mark with legal troubles, he would be right before or right after Deuce....

[bwzabodyn]

Dom Davis over Dillon - Henry over Dom... again Henry is way overrated this year and will pay big dividends for those that still him after the 3rd...

[Warpigs]

Dom Davis over Dillon - Henry over Dom... again Henry is way overrated this year and will pay big dividends for those that still him after the 3rd...

Overrated??

[sleeper]

What does stilling someone in the 3rd mean?

[veg3ta21]

personally i think kevin jones belongs in at least the 7th tier (with suggs and barber) and maybe even in the 6th tier

[Plindsey88]

personally i think kevin jones belongs in at least the 7th tier (with suggs and barber) and maybe even in the 6th tier

Why? We don't know anything about how he'll play in the NFL, and we have no idea what Mariucci has up his sleeve regarding a possible RBBC... You might be right, or you might be dead wrong... That's why I stuck him where I did... He's an unknown...