I don't put much stock in the preseason games, I do however find them reaffirming my prediction that Michael Vick is going to be a bust as a franchise QB.
I never bought into the 3000 passing yards/1000 rushing yards as being godlike. I guess that's because Randal Cunningham came about 50 rushing yards shy of accomplishing that once, and it didn't make him a game altering QB.
I've always been skeptical of his 55% completion percentage. Yes, his WRs were bad, but other QBs managed better percentages with just as bad if not worse WRs. I've also never liked his scrambling style. Whenever I've seen him scramble he runs like how a novice snowboarder goes down the mountain. That whole pendelum action, running side to side and just backing up further and further, it's not very good scrambling in my opinion because it puts him 20 yards behind the line of scrimmage. The only time I've seen him step up while scrambling is when he's tucked the ball and started to run.
Also there's just the fact that his running ability is his primary talent and seems to be his first option. He's a QB, he needs to be able to throw, and Vick has yet to show himself to be even above average in this regard. Having a QB that can run is nice, but having one that can throw is necessary. Without it, you wont have a passing attack, and will not make the superbowl.