Who would you choose Hilliard or Northcutt?

[a1doug182]

If you had to choose between the Ike Hilliard or Dennis Northcutt who would you want on your roster?

[IRON CHEF]

North - 2 - da - cut

[tomkatt]

Ike Hilliard.

[Members Only Jackets_ffc]

Out of those 2 I'll pass and select Andre Davis.

[TTTBone]

I'd go Hilliard, or I'd go elsewhere.

[dfer]

Hrm... shoot yourself in the foot... or shoot yourself in the hand...

Both gentlemen aren't even the first look on terrible teams with serious QB and line issues. However, I'd say Ike Hilliard gets the nod because at least he'll be on the field most of the time.

[inferno19]

Dennis Northcutt, solely because of his speed and punt return chances.

[ike301]

they're going to double toomer at some point (if and when he gets hot),and leave hilliard on a one-on-one. no?

[Shatner8]

Id definitely go with Hilliard

[kanezfan11]

I'd take Hilliard too. Northcutt isn't even guaranteed to play while Hilliard is the #2 with nobody looking to take his spot yet.