I wouldn't take this trade. Both your players are better than his three, so you seem to have a nice pat hand. Generally, you want to be careful about trading quality for quantity. The superstuds take you the distance, while a roster full of 2nd tier players won't. If the third player (in this case Barlow) had some strong upside (i.e., high risk, high reward), then maybe. Fred Taylor comes to mind. But Barlow doesn't quite qualify in my book.