Trade Analysis Needed

[trentvaughn]

Daunte Culpepper, Amani Toomer and Charlie Garner for

Michael Vick, Deuce McAllister and Edgerrin James

What do you think?
Who gets a better deal?

Trentvaughn

[kashikis]

not to be a pain in you butt here but could you post your team roster so i could see why your looking at this trade

both sides equal out in talent so its a very hard choice and theres more risks with the second team either youth or injury and id like to know what you'd have to fall back on etc.

[cloro]

Vick, Duece and the edge seems like the better deal. I would take it.

[trentvaughn]

My roster is:

Culpepper, Green, Couch and Holcomb (picked up just in case of this trade)
Homes, Garner, and Jamel White at RB (tough draft)
Toomer, Morton, Moulds and Mason at WR

What do you think?

Trentvaughn

[thechill]

Vick/Green /Couch(Holcomb) should all put up decent Fantasy numbers.
you lose a little with Culpepper

you upgrade and add depth at RB
I like Garner, but doubt if he puts those numbers up all year
between Duece/Edge/Holmes you have a nice backfield

which leaves you a little thin at WR with only Moulds and Mason

Morton lets hope since I have him as well puts up better numbers

once Couch is playing again you can drop Holcomb and pick up a WR on the waivers that would help for bye weeks and depth.

I would do this trade.

[kashikis]

now that i see what you have i can say that the second group will help you out because of your lack of RB

so do the trade

[n_tremain23]

If you have Garner,I would say a solid pickup to get would be Tyrone Wheatley.He looks like he could cut a little into Garner's playing time,just enough to where you could pick him up in case Garner goes down,doesn't perform,or Wheatley performs.Just a thought though.