SwiperNoSwiping wrote:I am not 'hating'
What I am saying is that I don't see how I would rank him ahead of Manning, Culpepper, Hasselback, McNabb, and Vick when healthy. Cases can be made for Pennington as well after his start.
Don't let the fact that he is clearly on your favorite team cloud your judgement. He is a very good QB, just not top 4 in my opinion.
I totally agree with this,with the exception of Vick.McNair is 10 times the QB Vick will ever be.While Vick does have the occasional huge game,Mcnair has been having good games consistently for years.Let Vick run for 100 and pass for nearly 200 every week,for at least 1 full year,then we can start considering putting him in the top 5 or 6.Til then,I'll be more than happy with Stevie Mac.