Trade evaluation

[Guest]

What do you think of this trade?

Randy the Moss for:

Fred Taylor and Jimmy Smith

[Arlo]

I think I'd rather have the Taylor/Smith side, injury history and all. The potential reward seems higher well worth the risk here.

The trade depends on the depth of the league too, however. In a very shallow league, Moss plus the extra roster spot might have more value.

[Guest]

not a big moss fan here. When/if he plays he has upside, but he will also get you a lot of 4 catches for 50 yard days.

I would rather have Taylor/Smith combo

I think Taylor stays healthy all year(yes I am a owner)

downside is that they are on the same team and that team is not stellar.

I would keep taylor and try and trade off Smith for equal caliber player such as holt/boston/r smith/etc...

added note grab Mack just in case*

so do the trade is your the one getting taylor/smith