Every year there's a QB disappointment. Reember how McNabb started the season last year? Last year I got McNair in the 8th round. This year he went in the 6th. Still not that bad of a deal, especially if you got Pennington to plug into the lineup while McNair figures things out.
Manning seems like the only QB who lives up to his billing every year. C-Pep sucked two years ago, McNabb last year, McNair this year, Warner -- you know the story, Gannon -- had his one year of unstopability. Manning is the most consistent. Though I think McNabb can be that way too. C-Pep just turns the ball over too much.