timzak wrote:I ask because all the preseason talk was that Duckett was a better fit for the new West Coast offense and he was ranked higher than Dunn in most of the preseason rank lists. I don't own him, but he was part of a trade I was considering. I'm probably going to turn the trade down because of his lack of playing time.
Not so...i went on every forum i could think of to correct this misconception...dunn is a way better fit for the west coast offense...he catches the ball out of the backfield and is the type of player that can make people miss in the open field...what west coast offense team has had a slow, plodding rb do well? Duckett has no value except as a handcuff to dunn.
I have to say that every website I went to besides the cafe in the offseason said that Duckett was the better pick. Meanwhile guys like Plindsey and KG were talkin about how much better Dunn would fit into the WCO.
i had a draft robot do my draft, and it managed to pick Mike Vick and Pats D as my FIRST TWO picks, and it finished up with TJ Duckett, Garrison Hearst, and Keenen McCardell as some of my other picks.
I dont think it could have made worse decisions if it was specically programmed to
NFL.COM
The Cheetahs featuring Michael Vick and one bad ass Defense
bebop82 wrote:i had a draft robot do my draft, and it managed to pick Mike Vick and Pats D as my FIRST TWO picks, and it finished up with TJ Duckett, Garrison Hearst, and Keenen McCardell as some of my other picks.
I dont think it could have made worse decisions if it was specically programmed to
Siggyfawn wrote:Goal line back? You obviously don't have a clue about Duckett.
First of all, he's not even a power runner. That's part of the problem, he dances around and doesn't run people over. He best runs are to the edge/outside.
And this year his only carries are NOT on the goal line. Dunn has gotten it everytime, which is why he has 4 rushing TDs. Even in short yardage, they don't bring in Duckett.
It's been the same old story, no one knows why Duckett doesn't get carries. He never got it under Reeves, and seems the new coaching staff isn't too impressed either. He also does stupid thinks like refusing to do the off-season workouts, prefering to workout at home w/ his own trainer.
Anyway Duckett won't get any TDs, and he won't get any carries unless Dunn gets hurt.
Duckett most certainly is more of a goal line back than Warrick Dunn is... Now, I could be wrong, but I don't think I've seen the Falcons with the ball inside the 5, yet... And so, we haven't seen Duckett in the ballgame in that situation, but I ask you this:
If you have the ball at the 1-foot line, and you need to slam it in between the tackles, who do you give the ball to:
Warrick Dunn - 5'8", 185 lbs ???
or
TJ Duckett - 6'0", 255 lbs ???
Sorry but YES you are wrong, by far, this is just runs 5 yards and under:
ARZ vs ATL
2-5-ARI5 (8:44) W.Dunn left tackle to ARZ 4 for 1 yard (R.Kolodziej)
ATL vs STL
1-4-STL4 (6:07) W.Dunn right tackle to SL 3 for 1 yard (E.Flowers)
1-2-STL2 (9:46) W.Dunn right tackle for 2 yards, TOUCHDOWN
4-1-STL2 (12:40) W.Dunn right tackle for 2 yards, TOUCHDOWN
SF vs ATL
1-2-SF2 (6:30) W.Dunn up the middle for 2 yards, TOUCHDOWN