Clinton Portis or Chris Brown?

[bmd]

Who will put up the better numbers this season? Brown has looked excellent to start the season. Will he keep it up? Portis was the stud back coming into the season. Who will end up the better back this year?

[moochman]

It's early, but how can you pick against Clinton? Well, I guess by looking at the stats. Brown has gone up against two Ds that were tough against the run and put up 100yds and a TD. Now McNair is banged up so he O should go through Brown more. I'd say Brown has a good shot to end up with more rushing yards.

[BrutallyHuge]

Brown, by a decent amount.

[Amazinz]

Brown, by a decent amount.

This clinches the deal. If Brutal likes Brown, I'll take Portis. Brutal is like the kiss of death with his predictions.

But seriously, at this point how do you not go with Portis? I'm on the Brown bandwagon but I think he still has a lot to prove before I start selecting him over a guy like Portis.

[Vlad the Impaler_ffc]

I still like Portis. I think he looked pretty decent last night against a physical Dallas D. If he could have just plunged in for a couple of 1 yard scores, everyone would be talking about what a great game he had.

[BrutallyHuge]

Instead we're talking about the great game Brown had against the best Rush D in the NFL.