The Edge or Fred Taylor?

[jewejt1]

Pretty close if you ask me. Which would you take?

[boojee]

Fred-dy Fred-dy

[fabie]

the Edge no doubt

[terpfan]

james... hes less of an injury risk than freddy, and better when he is healthy. (which i dont think he is 100%...)

[SolarfluX]

Milk Taylor for all he's worth before he gets injured again. Edge won't do much vs. a strong Miami D, not to mention it hasn't even been a year since he tore his ACL...

[n_tremain23]

Stick with Edge.

[terpfan]

seems like a split crowd. let me specify my response. if u mean for the entire season id take james, but for this week taylor is the better play.

[taylorsouth]

if you're in a keeper league, James is much better than Taylor and should be in your top ten selection, IMHO. If you're playing for this year, wait for James to round into mid season shape. He won't risk his injury for yardage, so give James a few games to get into a groove.