Better here on out - McCareins or Gardner?

[miracle]

Who is a better bet for the rest of the season - Justin McCareins or Rod Gardner?

[Smizzy]

Id say that it's a wash

[no1cowboysfan]

Ummm... both will likely be good #3 receivers (or #2, depending on league depth). Both look ok to me... but probably McCareins by a little bit.

[bald1]

it seems to be virtually universally excepted that eventually c-mart will not keep up this pace. i have him and expect him to be solid and even better than last year here on out but not as outstanding as he has been to this point. i think that you will see pass attempts increase as the running games effectiveness dimishes even if marginally. at the very least, defenses will have to start stacking against the run more to stop the jets from controlling the clock as much as they seem to be. with the increase in pass attepmts i think you will see the value of penny, moss and mccareins increase. probably moss will see more receptions and yards and mccareins will see more td's(than moss) due to his size and ability in the red zone. moss will still get the bomb td's but as defs focus more on c-mart in the red zone, mccareins looks will increase. so i think mccareins has more value looking ahead. i hope anyway, i also have penny and have recently picked up mccareins to replace calico. calico and mccareins were my two sleeper picks for the year. penny has also stated that he thinks the receivers will end the year in the 70-80 catch range......go with mccareins.

[bald1]

it seems to be virtually universally excepted that eventually c-mart will not keep up this pace. i have him and expect him to be solid and even better than last year here on out but not as outstanding as he has been to this point. i think that you will see pass attempts increase as the running games effectiveness dimishes even if marginally. at the very least, defenses will have to start stacking against the run more to stop the jets from controlling the clock as much as they seem to be. with the increase in pass attepmts i think you will see the value of penny, moss and mccareins increase. probably moss will see more receptions and yards and mccareins will see more td's(than moss) due to his size and ability in the red zone. moss will still get the bomb td's but as defs focus more on c-mart in the red zone, mccareins looks will increase. so i think mccareins has more value looking ahead. i hope anyway, i also have penny and have recently picked up mccareins to replace calico. calico and mccareins were my two sleeper picks for the year. penny has also stated that he thinks the receivers will end the year in the 70-80 catch range......go with mccareins.

[Jscupa]

has McCareins had a 160 yd 2 td game yet?

NO

gardner has

[Trap]

Are you a homer?

Yes.

[kanezfan11]

Are you a homer?

Yes.

Lol.

I love his roster too:

QB: B.leftwhich, C.Palmer, V.Testeverde, brunell
RB: A.Green, C. Dillion, Q. Griffin
WR: C.Johnson, D.Jackson, A.toomer, R.Gardner
TE: K.Winslow, B.Franks, C. Cooley
K: J.hall, Graham
Def: Redskins, panthers

-----

IMO, I think they'll be a wash also.

[Jscupa]

do any of them start?
NO

am I undefeated?

YES

thanks
sit down

[34=Sweetness]

do any of them start?
NO

am I undefeated?

YES

thanks
sit down

Are you lying?
Probably.

Anyways, its pretty close. Gardners numbers would be awful if not for that one fluke game.