Is Javon Walker a Sell High?

[moochman]

I don't think that Walker is going to fade away. He has all of the physical tools and all of the intangibles: a good QB, a high scoring offense, and a sucky defense. That said I would accept the trade for Deuce. Deuce is ready to resume his spot as a top drawer stud. You could always target someone who doesn't have great RBs and dump Dillon for a top WR.

[iloveny18]

I don't think that Walker is going to fade away. He has all of the physical tools and all of the intangibles: a good QB, a high scoring offense, and a sucky defense. That said I would accept the trade for Deuce. Deuce is ready to resume his spot as a top drawer stud. You could always target someone who doesn't have great RBs and dump Dillon for a top WR.

you kinda made points for both arguements. i'm thinking about it, but can duece really com back to be the consistent 20ppg guy he was?

[The Great Gambini]

I don't think that Walker is going to fade away. He has all of the physical tools and all of the intangibles: a good QB, a high scoring offense, and a sucky defense. That said I would accept the trade for Deuce. Deuce is ready to resume his spot as a top drawer stud. You could always target someone who doesn't have great RBs and dump Dillon for a top WR.

you kinda made points for both arguements. i'm thinking about it, but can duece really com back to be the consistent 20ppg guy he was?

Yes.

[CC]

I don't think that Walker is going to fade away. He has all of the physical tools and all of the intangibles: a good QB, a high scoring offense, and a sucky defense. That said I would accept the trade for Deuce. Deuce is ready to resume his spot as a top drawer stud. You could always target someone who doesn't have great RBs and dump Dillon for a top WR.

you kinda made points for both arguements. i'm thinking about it, but can duece really com back to be the consistent 20ppg guy he was?

Yes.

No dizzobut.

[BMadd]

OK, Come on fellas. Javon is having a terrific year, no doubt. But you absolutely HAVE to take McAllister in a straight up trade. You would be foolish not to, I don't care how many RBs you have.

[Ironhorse75]

^

So having a stacked running game (plenty of bench points) is better than a well rounded pass/run team?

[Kensat30]

I would trade Walker straight up for an underperforming preseason top5 WR. Harrison and Holt would be at the top of the list. Sell high and lock in the guy that is pretty much guaranteed to be in the top10 for the full year, rather than the guy who has had a HUGE week before the season is even half over. If Walker put up 100 yards and a TD instead of 200/3 in week 3 is there any way you can get a Holt or Harrison for him? I highly doubt it.

[iloveny18]

i won't do it. i looked at the pack's schedule and they play some pretty bad pass D's. the problem with this league, is that everyone seems to have thier Rb's and no one wants to trade or offers unfair trades, so having a wr here is golden. i agree with kensat30 though, that's why i'm trying to sell. i'd do the duece trade in a second if i can get good value for dillon (or ahman), but it's just not happening for me